Popular Searches
Print
E-mail
Comment
Rate
Share
Protesters take issue with Murphy’s vote on health care
 |
| Protesters gather outside the Hudson office of Congressman Scott Murphy Thursday to protest his “no” vote on the health care reform bill currently headed to the floor of the senate. (Robert Ragaini/Hudson-Catskill Newspapers) |
By Jamie Larson
Columbia County Democrats, organized by MoveOn.org, rallied outside, and inside, the Hudson district office of U.S. Rep. Scott Murphy Thursday.
The protesters were there to voice their displeasure over the congressman’s “no” vote on the health care reform bill which narrowly passed in the House of Representatives by five votes Saturday.
Murphy was one of 39 Democrats who voted against the bill, championed by President Barack Obama.
Protesters said they wanted Murphy to hear their disappointment and remind him that his vote is contrary to the will of those in Columbia County who helped get him elected in the extremely close special election this year.
The group presented Murphy’s Constituent Representative Zigis Switzer with a report card they made for Murphy. While the congressman got all passing grades for his support of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, education and credit reform, and initiatives bringing business to upstate New York, he received a bright red “Failed” for his “no” on health care reform.
“We’re disappointed he didn’t vote for this bill,” Robert Bisson said at the curbside. “A lot of us are disappointed in this bill, in terms of things like his stance on abortion rights, but that can be fixed.”
Though he voted against the health care bill, a statement released by his office Thursday said Murphy has consistently supported reform but disagreed with the way bill H.R. 3962 addressed the problem. “Congress should not pass a trillion dollar health overhaul that would leave our families and small businesses left paying more for health care, not less,” the statement reads.
The statement goes on to say that the bill fails at “protecting small businesses by exempting only those small businesses with payrolls below $500,000 from the pay or play scheme and only provides small businesses with health care tax credits for two years; imposes billions of dollars in taxes on medical device companies and paper mills — two of the largest private employers in the 20th District; fails to change incentives in the system by not containing delivery reform and maintaining a Fee For Service model; and does not include the necessary consumer protections to ensure that insurance companies could not unjustifiably raise premiums leaving our families and small business to pick up the tab.”
One protester said that while Murphy worries about a 2 percent tax increase on manufacturers killing business, the current health care system is killing people.
Peter Donahoe of Stuyvesant said Murphy received 10 percent of his margin of victory in the county from Stuyvesant and he has lost much, if not all of it with his health care vote.
“He blew it,” Donahoe said, holding up his own Scott Murphy election lawn signs with the congressman’s name crossed out in paint. “Anyone who thinks we’ll put these signs on our lawns for him again better think again.”
Donahoe gave the lawn signs to Switzer, saying he wouldn’t be needing them anymore.
Murphy announced Thursday that he will be hosting a tele-town hall conference at 7:10 p.m. Monday to continue the discussion on health care reform and the economy, and he invites the people of the 20th District to participate and ask questions and express their views.
Those interested in participating must call Murphy’s office at 202-225-5614 by 5 p.m. today, or e-mail NY20.townhall@mail.house.gov with their name, address, and phone number by noon Sunday to be added to the list.
Those who have signed up will receive a phone call Monday evening inviting them to join the call.
To reach reporter Jamie Larson, call 518-828-1616, ext. 2269, or e-mail jlarson@registerstar.com.
The protesters were there to voice their displeasure over the congressman’s “no” vote on the health care reform bill which narrowly passed in the House of Representatives by five votes Saturday.
Murphy was one of 39 Democrats who voted against the bill, championed by President Barack Obama.
Protesters said they wanted Murphy to hear their disappointment and remind him that his vote is contrary to the will of those in Columbia County who helped get him elected in the extremely close special election this year.
The group presented Murphy’s Constituent Representative Zigis Switzer with a report card they made for Murphy. While the congressman got all passing grades for his support of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, education and credit reform, and initiatives bringing business to upstate New York, he received a bright red “Failed” for his “no” on health care reform.
“We’re disappointed he didn’t vote for this bill,” Robert Bisson said at the curbside. “A lot of us are disappointed in this bill, in terms of things like his stance on abortion rights, but that can be fixed.”
Though he voted against the health care bill, a statement released by his office Thursday said Murphy has consistently supported reform but disagreed with the way bill H.R. 3962 addressed the problem. “Congress should not pass a trillion dollar health overhaul that would leave our families and small businesses left paying more for health care, not less,” the statement reads.
The statement goes on to say that the bill fails at “protecting small businesses by exempting only those small businesses with payrolls below $500,000 from the pay or play scheme and only provides small businesses with health care tax credits for two years; imposes billions of dollars in taxes on medical device companies and paper mills — two of the largest private employers in the 20th District; fails to change incentives in the system by not containing delivery reform and maintaining a Fee For Service model; and does not include the necessary consumer protections to ensure that insurance companies could not unjustifiably raise premiums leaving our families and small business to pick up the tab.”
One protester said that while Murphy worries about a 2 percent tax increase on manufacturers killing business, the current health care system is killing people.
Peter Donahoe of Stuyvesant said Murphy received 10 percent of his margin of victory in the county from Stuyvesant and he has lost much, if not all of it with his health care vote.
“He blew it,” Donahoe said, holding up his own Scott Murphy election lawn signs with the congressman’s name crossed out in paint. “Anyone who thinks we’ll put these signs on our lawns for him again better think again.”
Donahoe gave the lawn signs to Switzer, saying he wouldn’t be needing them anymore.
Murphy announced Thursday that he will be hosting a tele-town hall conference at 7:10 p.m. Monday to continue the discussion on health care reform and the economy, and he invites the people of the 20th District to participate and ask questions and express their views.
Those interested in participating must call Murphy’s office at 202-225-5614 by 5 p.m. today, or e-mail NY20.townhall@mail.house.gov with their name, address, and phone number by noon Sunday to be added to the list.
Those who have signed up will receive a phone call Monday evening inviting them to join the call.
To reach reporter Jamie Larson, call 518-828-1616, ext. 2269, or e-mail jlarson@registerstar.com.
Share this Article
 |
 |
|
| Structure fire at fire chief’s State St. house | Alleged stabber walks |
Article Rating
Reader Comments
The following are comments from the readers. In no way do they represent the view of registerstar.com.
Rogue wrote on Nov 13, 2009 8:24 AM:
" People are entitled to their opinions so I say, congratulations Congressman Murphy on a very wise decsion regarding your vote on healthcare reform. You picked up my vote for the next election and many others to be sure. Please don't give in to the pressures of your party. Yes, healthcare does need to be reformed, and yes, people should have affordable healthcare provided for them, but we ought not to increase the deficit by mind numbing numbers to do it. Anyone who has children ought to appreciate that we need to find a better way to finance healthcare reform short of hijacking our children's futures with even more debt from China & India. Hang tough, many people are in your corner supporting you. "
upstateapples wrote on Nov 13, 2009 10:34 AM:
" Murphy listened to the voters and made the wise decision. Coming from a business background, he obviously understood the cost impact this particular reform would have on taxpayers. "
cocoloco wrote on Nov 13, 2009 11:32 AM:
" unfortunately, the "cost" to taxpayers only increases year by year without health care reform. murphy playing old politics. he was elected on a true democratic platform. he failed us. "
OV Observer wrote on Nov 13, 2009 4:46 PM:
" Rogue, According to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office, the House health reform bill is not only deficit-neutral, it reduces the deficit by over $100 billion over the next decade. "
stonepound wrote on Nov 13, 2009 5:45 PM:
" Would we really be better off with that drunk republican Sweeney? "
Rogue wrote on Nov 17, 2009 8:21 PM:
" OV, Respectfully, I don't buy it. You can't have something for nothing. But for the sake of argument, let's assume that you are right on the money. (No pun intended) Have you ever known a federal social program to not increase in costs? It's going to cost us plenty one way or the other but thank you for your respectful feedback to my comment. Best wishes.
Stonepound,
I am a proud Republican but I didn't care for the job Sweeny did so I voted for Gilibrand. When people get too comforable with their jobs, they need to go. "
Stonepound,
I am a proud Republican but I didn't care for the job Sweeny did so I voted for Gilibrand. When people get too comforable with their jobs, they need to go. "
You must register with a valid email to post comments. Only your Member ID will be posted with the comments.
Registered users sign in here: |
Become a Registered User |
riverhouse222 wrote on Nov 13, 2009 7:14 AM:
Murphy got my vote (once)! Next election independent all the way.
Murphy blew it! "